First of all, everyone’s dynasty roster is in a different state. If you’re going for it you’ll happily trade an unproven rookie for a stable senior citizen QB.
The list below is how I would view these players’ trade values for the season ahead.
| Rank | Player | Age | Comment |
| 1 | Russell Wilson | 29 | MVP/HOF calibre despite coaching |
| 2 | Aaron Rodgers | 34 | MVP/HOF calibre despite coaching |
| 3 | Matt Stafford | 30 | Steady as she goes. Crazy weapons |
| 4 | Cam Newton | 29 | Feels like a time bomb |
| 5 | Andrew Luck | 28 | Higher if he’s right |
| 6 | Carson Wentz | 25 | 1 more season cements value |
| 7 | Marcus Mariota | 24 | Lofty position that needs to be earned |
| 8 | Deshaun Watson | 22 | Nice start, show me more |
| 9 | Matt Ryan | 33 | A strong career finish coming |
| 10 | Jared Goff | 23 | Progress, but mighty D/Run game is a ceiling |
| 11 | Lamar Jackson | 21 | Runs and throws well |
| 12 | Pat Mahomes | 22 | Throws well and runs |
| 13 | Jameis Winston | 24 | Maturity misteps proving to be an anchor |
| 14 | Jimmy Garoppolo | 26 | Overhyped, overpriced |
| 15 | Philip Rivers | 36 | Shot put gold medalist |
| 16 | Ben Roethlisberger | 36 | Armed with star-studded cast |
| 17 | Drew Brees | 39 | Last gasp: return of the air game |
| 18 | Mitch Turbisky | 23 | Mariota, with a coaching headstart |
| 19 | Josh Rosen | 21 | He can take this job early |
| 20 | Eli Manning | 37 | Roethlisberger-like cast |
| 21 | Sam Darnold | 21 | Ideally he is afforded a learning year |
| 22 | Tom Brady | 41 | Old man vs AFC east |
| 23 | Baker Mayfield | 23 | Has to overcome a curse od Cleveland |
| 24 | Kirk Cousins | 29 | New team/system. Not as young as you think |
| 25 | Blake Bortles | 26 | Underhyped, underpriced |
| 26 | Derek Carr | 27 | Possibly horrible |
| 27 | Chad Kelly | 24 | Probably best Broncos QB now |
| 28 | Dak Prescott | 25 | Must overcome lack of coaching and weapons |
| 29 | Alex Smith | 34 | You’re not in Kansas (City) anymore |
| 30 | Andy Dalton | 30 | Boring us into submission. Possible surprise |
| 31 | Teddy Bridgewater | 25 | Deserves a chance to be a #1 |
| 32 | Josh Allen | 22 | Poison narrative makes him a value play |
| 33 | Ryan Tannehill | 30 | Reclamation project. Perhaps Gase turns it around |
| 34 | Mason Rudolph | 23 | Long wait behind stubborn jerk |
| 35 | Kyle Lauletta | 22 | Probably not the heir apparent but a lifetime backup |
| 36 | Case Keenum | 30 | Journeyman killing time looking for QB1 |
| 37 | Joe Flacco | 33 | The big yawn. Lamar push may provide minor lift |
| 38 | Tyrod Taylor | 29 | Denied a real shot, Cleveland will rush Mayfield |
